The Doubt We Feel When Leaders Fail

By Josiah Bancroft on September 01, 2015

When I hear how public church leaders fail, I find that my own pride or doubts show up. I wonder how it is possible that they could betray Christ, their family, those in the church they led. Or I begin to doubt my trust in Christ. I mentally tick off how what I believe and do is better and I feel superior and safe. Or I see how close I have come to disaster and feel hypocritical because of my own struggles. 

Recently, I re-engaged John Bunyan’s, Grace to the Chief of Sinners. I also found a summary of that 17th century classic. In the summary, I found two lists that I have made my own. Bunyan’s insights still hold up and encourage me to trust Jesus and his promises and also to keep an eye on my faith. I revised the lists to make them mine, something I can easily say that is true for me today. See what you think.

I find to this day seven evil things in my heart that I hate: 

I easily fall into unbelief.

I can suddenly forget the love and mercy that Christ has shown me.

I lean toward the works of the law.

I wander and am often cold in prayer.

I forget to watch and expect the things I pray for. 

I complain because I want more, but I often abuse what I already have.

I can do none of the things that God commands me, and the desires of my flesh assert themselves, “When I would do good, evil is present with me.”

These things I continually see and feel. They afflict and oppress me; yet God’s wisdom uses even the things that distress me for my good:

They make me hate the part of me that is rebellious against God—my “flesh.”

They keep me from trusting my motives*.

They convince me that I can never trust my own righteousness because it is never enough.

They show me the necessity of running quickly to Jesus.

They require me to pray constantly.

They show me that I have to watch myself and keep alert.

And they force me to look to God, through Christ, to help me, and carry me through life.

I find the honesty from Bunyan clear, authentic, and encouraging. His focus on Jesus’ work and love helps me. I resonate with Bunyan’s word about trusting my own righteousness. The original said that when Bunyan saw the evil remaining in his heart he realized “the insufficiency of all inherent righteousness.” That helped me because I can slide into thinking of righteousness as a thing. It becomes something that is subtly separate from Christ. The truth is, as I believe in Jesus, His righteousness, never mine, is my best hope for real change in my life and for daily enjoyment of God.

(The summary is available here.)

You can download the whole book for free in various forms at ‘Project Gutenberg.’)

* I need the guidance of the Holy Spirit, wisdom of the Scripture, and godly counsel to check/form my motives

Josiah Bancroft

About Josiah Bancroft

Josiah and his wife Barbara have a long history with Serge. You may recognize Josiah from his active involvement as a speaker for the Sonship Course. Josiah brings his experience as a pastor (most recently of Grace Community Church in Asheville, NC) and church planter (in Ireland, Louisiana, and Alabama) to lead Serge as the Director of Mission. He writes and speaks about God's transforming grace at